Press "Enter" to skip to content

$187k For Grooming Instruction

The March 28, 2016 meeting of the Fort Bragg City Council was held at Town Hall located in Fort Bragg. Council members Doug Hammerstrom, Scott Deitz and Mike Cimolino were present as well as Vice Mayor Lindy Peters and Mayor Dave Turner. Tom Varga-Public Works Director, Fabian E. Lizarraga-Chief of Police, Linda Ruffing-City Manager, June Lemos-City Clerk, Scott Schneider-Adminstrative Services Director and Samantha Zutler-Attorney were in attendance as well.

Item 1a. on the agenda was the Mayor’s recognitions and announcements.

Councilman Cimolino presented Rosalie Gjerde with a Proclamation declaring April 2016 as “Child Abuse and Neglect Prevention Month.” A copy of the proclamation can be found at the City’s website.

It was disturbing to hear Ms. Gjerde give the numbers of child abuse cases in Mendocino County as being twice as high as the State average.

Item 1b. was a presentation by Leadership Mendocino Executive Director Heidi Cusick Dickerson and the 2015 Scholarship Recipients.

Item 1c. was a presentation regarding Northwest California Alternative Fuels Readiness Project (AFRP). PowerPoint presentation (see also City website).

Item 1d. Proclamation of the Fort Bragg City Council Expressing Continuing Support and Admiration for the Town of Otsuchi, Japan on the Occasion of the Inauguration of a New Community Facility at Namiita Beach. Mayor Turner has asked the community to donate any sea glass they may have on hand so it can be sent to the Namiita Beach Facility. You can drop your glass off at City Hall.

During public comment on non-agenda items Debra DeGraw Vice President of the Fort Bragg Promotion Committee thanked Council and staff for the new downtown wi-fi. Cards are in the mail with info on “claim your listing” on the new website. Debra and the team will be at Town Hall on the second Saturday in April to help local businesses get their information onto the website. This is all made possible by the new downtown wi-fi.

Judy Valadao spoke about what a wonderful job the Redwood Coast Senior Citizens have done with their garden. Judy brought a photo taken from the Advocate News to show how great the winter garden looks with its many winter vegetables. She pointed out all the work was done and the garden is a success without a grant of $187,000. (Referring to the grant given to the Hospitality Center for their Giving Garden last year. The Giving Garden, according President Gary Johnson, is not for teaching or learning about gardening but is instead for teaching grooming and how to interview.) Judy said the success of the Senior Garden proves to her that it isn’t the money that makes for success but instead the willingness to put the work into the garden.

Judy asked if anyone had noticed the increase in people on the City streets. Not tourists but homeless. She pointed out that Redway and Eureka are cleaning up the homeless camps around their area and those people seem to be headed for Fort Bragg. Who wouldn’t she asked. They have free meals every day of the week, a park to sleep in and shelter when it’s rainy or cold. She went on to say it seems the grants are not helping and suggested some sort of work program. We have a park that needs to be cleaned as well as the Glass Beach Trail, Noyo Headlands Trail, Johnson Park and Pomo Bluff. Perhaps if these people had work to do they could become involved in the community and maybe even feel better about themselves.

Jay Rosenquist spoke of errors in the Impartial Analysis of Measure U that will appear on the June Ballot. Jay stated City Attorney Samatha Zutler had written the Impartial Analysis. And then pointed out someone being paid a quarter of million dollars a year and making errors on an important document such as this is an embarrassment to Community.

Douglas Chouteau read a letter written by a number of local residents on the subject of the homeless. The letter told of the murder of Denis Boardman, the death of a young lady whose body was found near the haul road, the stabbing of a local woman by a transient wanted out of Montana and the rape of a young woman and a transient out of Tennessee being arrested for the rape. The letter went on to say with Redway and Eureka tightening their belts on the homeless situation perhaps Fort Bragg should do the same. One suggestion was background checks for those receiving the services of free food, free clothing, free lodging (sometimes in local motels). Background checks would bolster safety for everyone including the residents who live and work in Fort Bragg and the most vulnerable, the homeless, women, children and the tourists that we want to attract. A round of applause was heard after Mr. Chouteau finished reading the letter.

Eric Dwyer spoke of some grates on the Coastal Trails that need some attention as he feels children or puppies could fall in and be washed out to sea.

George Reinhart said he was very pleased with the alternative fuels presentation. He spoke of the local Mendo Alcohol Fuel Group working on an alternative fuel here on the coast. George said some information in the presentation was not correct (if you get the chance watch the video, George is always interesting to listen to).

Item 6a. Receive Ad Hoc Committee Report on interviews with lodging owners regarding the TOT to be placed on the November Ballot. A link to the breakdown of the interviews is provided at the City website.

The meeting went past 10pm at this point but Councilman Peters made a motion to continue the meeting. It was seconded, so the meeting continued.

Item 6b. Receive report and provide direction to staff regarding use of Electric Personal Assistive Mobility Devices on the Coastal Trail. I’m finding it impossible to come up with words to describe this report and entire discussion by Council and Staff. A permit was issued to North Coast Segway. I believe Lynne Baumgartner filed for and received the permit in good faith but the confusion that followed by the City is nothing short of a circus. Three hours into the linked video you can watch and hear the entire discussion. It seemed to me not one person on the Council or Staff had a clue what was going on and the exchange between Doug Hammerstrom and City Attorney would take days to break down into anything that made any sort of sense.

I’m sure we haven’t heard the last of the Segway discussion. I just hope the next time it comes up someone has a clue what they are talking about and what the rules are. Too bad this happened to someone who was just trying to start a business and follow the rules.


  1. John Kriege April 6, 2016

    If city staff led Ms. Baumgartner to believe that Segway tours would be allowed on the Coatal Trail, they really blew it. But the the use of Segways on the Trail is a bad idea, and I am glad to hear that Coastal Conservancy rules apparently prohibit it.

    • Judy Valadao April 8, 2016

      It isn’t Noyo Headlands, it’s the Glass Beach Trail.

  2. BB Grace April 6, 2016

    “In a time of universal deceit – telling the truth is a revolutionary act.” – George Orwell

    “Jay Rosenquist spoke of errors in the Impartial Analysis of Measure U that will appear on the June Ballot. Jay stated City Attorney Samatha Zutler had written the Impartial Analysis. And then pointed out someone being paid a quarter of million dollars a year and making errors on an important document such as this is an embarrassment to Community.”

    Is it possible to share the list of errors in the IMPARTIAL Analysis of Measure U? Can the list be published in the FB Ad with the fact Zutler wrote the impartial Analysis? FB City Attorney Samantha Zutler is impartial? How can that be?

    Judy Valadao made a good point comparing gardens. Did anyone care? Isn’t the money for gardens or grooming really just money for salaries, and since jobs, governmetn jobs, government contract jobs, are the only jobs that pay a living wage in FB, how can we knock those grants for hundreds of thousands, or millions? How else can they afford to go to Wine Song and Crab Dinners their clients can’t?

    My guess is being a religion organization is why the Hospitality Center doesn’t do background checks? Quite a contortion isn’t it, a religious organization bending everyway it can for that all mighty dollar and playing monopoly buying up real estate. This must be the “Secular Church” folks keep telling me about?

  3. izzy April 8, 2016

    Talk about “embarrassment to the community”. Or maybe it’s just over-impetuosity in the announcement. For whatever reason, the web link goes nowhere at this time. On the other hand, at least there is consistency.

  4. Judy Valadao April 8, 2016

    I have sent an email to the project manager of the Coastal Conservancy and will post the answer when I get it.

  5. Judy Valadao April 8, 2016

    Hi Judy-
    You are referring to the Glass Beach coastal trail that is separated from the road, correct?
    When the Coastal Conservancy funded the parkland acquisition and trail construction, we stipulated that the area was to be used for passive recreation. As part of that restriction, motorized vehicles can only be used by those that require them for mobility (disabled folks). Use of motorized vehicles as part of a commercial enterprise is not allowable because of this restriction. Here is the language from the Offer to Dedicate that the City recorded over the land regarding passive recreation:

    For the purposes of public access, passive recreation and natural resource, open space and scenic protection, as permitted by the bond act and the terms of the special deposit fund; and no use of the real property inconsistent with these purposes is permitted. As used in the paragraph, ‘passive recreation’ means those recreational activities typically associated with coastal open space that generally are non-structured and require minimal or no developed facilities or improvements to land. Such activities include walking, biking, jogging, hiking, dog walking, bird watching, tide-pooling, beach combing, informal sports activities such as Frisbee or ball throwing and kite-flying, nature viewing, picnicking, and public events that avoid impact to significant cultural and natural resources. Some improvements and ancillary facilities necessary to support visitor access to the coastal open space are permitted in connection with passive recreation uses, including, but not limited to, parking lots interpretive signage, visitor kiosks, trail and stairway improvements, benches and restrooms. Passive recreational activities do not include activities such as: playgrounds, community gardens, ball-fields, and skate parks. The uses enumerated in this paragraph as being included in or excluded from ‘passive recreation’ are by way of example only, and are not an exhaustive list of permitted or unpermitted uses, but may be used to illustrate the types of uses and facilities contemplated as being consistent with ‘passive recreation.’

    Note that motorized vehicles are not called out as an excluded use, but our legal staff has made the judgment that this use is excluded. Please let me know if you need more information about this issue.

    • Judy Valadao April 8, 2016

      Susie, I can’t argue the point because I don’t know. I only know that Joel is the project manager and this is what he said. I’m not saying he is right or wrong. I’m only putting out there what he said about the issue.

  6. Alice Chouteau April 8, 2016

    Sorry, but you are misinformed. Motorized vehicles of any kind are prohibited on all parts of the Coastal Trail, under use covenants in the agreetment between the Conservancy and the city. If you have time to watch that portion of the last council meeting, this ban is discussed. There is also a ban on commercial enterprises on the trail, so the Segway biz violated two covenants.
    It seem Ms Baumgarten was unaware of the convenants, but city staff should have checked before giving her a permit. At that meeting it is stated by several officials that ‘in hindsight’, issuing the permit was an error.

  7. Judy Valadao April 12, 2016

    Ms. Baumgartner tried to do everything according to the rules. That is the bottom line. She was upfront with the person she talked to about where her tours would be.

Leave a Reply to Judy Valadao Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.