Press "Enter" to skip to content

Please, Not A Country For Old Men

I’m not entirely certain what a country for old white men would look and feel like, but I have been thinking about that image/concept ever since I first saw the movie, No Country for Old Men, based on Cormac McCarthy’s neo-western of the same name. In the senior living facility where I’m currently living old women far outnumber old men like me. I’ll likely die here, though surely not in the kind of violence and with the hail of bullets that explode in McCarthy’s novel and in the movie, No Country for Old Men. All the old men and old women here are Democrats. There doesn’t seem to be a single Trumper in this place; if there is, that person is in hiding.

My friend S. calls this senior living facility a “dormitory.” It does have similarities with campus buildings where students sleep before, during and after classes. I prefer to think of my new home—and any studio apartment on the ninth floor—not as a dormitory, but as a hotel, though the place could also be described as a “country” for old men and old women, though they like to be thought of as elderly not old. It’s its own little world, and not a microcosm of the US. I moved here at the end of August from Ocean Beach in San Francisco because I got tired of the wind and the fog and the cold. It’s sunnier here on Post Street.

Like me, the residents have their own apartments, some larger than others, some smaller than others. We have kitchenettes and bathrooms. Downstairs in the dining room we can and usually do eat three meals a day: breakfast, lunch and supper. Tables have white tablecloths. Red and white wine is available. Waiters and waitresses do the serving; entrees are different every night and every noon. There’s a new movie on a big screen every day, seven days of the week, plus concerts and talks. Last Monday, I watched the 49ers beat the Jets on a big screen. I also saw Hitchcock’s Dial M for Muder.

It’s a luxury and a privilege to live here. I'm thankful for my pension that makes it possible.

I have met two-dozen or so residents and have made friends with seven or eight of them, most in their 90s, most mentally alert and physically frail, hard of hearing and reliant on canes and walkers. The director and the head chef are men, so this place can't really be called a matriarchy, though women do set the tone of serenity and practice good manners which are contagious. Arthur, who sits in a wheelchair at meals, will celebrate his 100th birthday in November. He remembers more than a dozen U.S. presidents, all men: Calvin Coolidge, Herbert Hoover, Franklin D. Roosevelt, Truman, Eisenhower, Kennedy, Nixon, Ford, Reagan, the Bushes, father and son, Clinton, Obama, and Biden. FDR was his favorite. Does the U.S. have a problem with gender? It would seem so.

Arthur and the other elderly men and elderly women in this hotel/dormitory have lived through wars and revolutions in Europe and Asia, as well as depressions and recessions in the US. Several survived fascism. A few of the residents rarely emerge from their apartments, but most residents come out for meals, conversations, events and films. It would be challenging to feel isolated, lonely and alienated here, though I’m sure that masochists and nihilists could talk themselves into states of alienation and loneliness.

If everyone, especially the old and the elderly, had the opportunity to live in a dormitory/hotel like the one where I live, they would probably not feel lost and lonely, at least not for long. Someone would come knocking on their door and invite them to come out and play. That’s what happens here. I’m not allowed to hide and sulk and that’s a good thing.

Slash the military budget the residents say and build housing that will bring people together in communities that will undermine the epidemic of loneliness that blankets the nation and that some have said is worse than the pandemic itself.

On September 10th almost all of the residents watched the debate between Kamala Harris and Donald Trump, the candidate who would like to turn the US into a country for old white men like himself, preferably wealthy, and definitely conservative. The residents here were jazzed by the debate. They think that Kamala came out the winner, but they’re worried and rightfully so about a Trump presidency. They believe he’ll try to wreck the government and become even more dictatorial than he was when he was president.

Kamala Harris might not win this time around, but in many ways, residents say, she represents the future, or at least a possible future, which is bound to be multi-ethnic. We are not yet only a country for old white men, so say the elderly men and elderly women in this facility, though we’re coming dangerously close.

My fellow residents believe that a vote for Trump is a vote for fossilized old white men. A vote for Harris is a vote for the future, they tell me. I know that some of my friends will argue about that. They’ll point out Harris’s flaws and faults of which there are many. True, we don’t know everything about her, as they insist, but we do know that she’s a woman, a person of color and that she’s brave enough to defy an old white man bound for the grave.

9 Comments

  1. Chris Nelson October 1, 2024

    Wonderfully written and truer words have never been spoken. It hurts my heart very much to think this country has as many citizens as it does who with a vote for Trump, whether they know it or not, are desecrating the souls and graves of all the World War II casualties and heroes. Thank you for your honesty and thank you for sharing your gratitude for both your current living situation and for your life in general.

  2. Allen Young October 2, 2024

    I am a longtime friend of writer Jonah Raskin, and we are the same age, but with a different reality, as I remain in my own home in a very rural setting in Massachusetts. If I didn’t have all the attachments I have here, and if I had the money, I’d move to San Francisco and move into Jonah’s place. It sounds pretty good to me. But with the help of my partner (who lives in another town), some cousins and neighbors, I am going to try to remain longer in my home. I hope to visit San Francisco sometime soon and will visit Jonah and we can dine together as they probably allow guests (for a fee!). I enjoyed reading this, with its upbeat tone. I wish there were no Trumpers in my area, but there are — almost half the people even though I’m in liberal Massachusetts.

  3. Pat Kittle October 2, 2024

    “The smart way to keep people passive and obedient is to strictly limit the spectrum of acceptable opinion, but allow very lively debate within that spectrum – even encourage the more critical and dissident views. That gives people the sense that there’s free thinking going on, while all the time the presuppositions of the system are being reinforced by the limits put on the range of the debate.”
    — Noam Chomsky

    Chomsky would likely agree:
    “To learn who rules over you, simply find out who you cannot criticize.”

    • Bruce Anderson October 2, 2024

      Who can’t you criticize, Kittle? Oh, of course. Don’t bother clarifying.

      • Pat Kittle October 3, 2024

        More to the point…

        Who can’t YOU criticize, Bruce? Oh, of course. Nothing to see here, move along.
        :-)

  4. Paul Modic October 2, 2024

    One of your best, kudos…

  5. Fran Moreland Johns October 25, 2024

    Fascinating. I’m an old woman (which hasn’t quite the cachet of old man) a couple of floors below the eloquent writer Raskin, same dorm, lucky to be a long time resident. We do have a number of closet Republicans, though no longer the group of agitators (progressives!) who used to wave protest posters on nearby thoroughfares. Life inside the dorm is indeed all-day active but some of us still thrive on life of the outside world including causes and goings-on plus the walkable hills and gritty downtown streets of San Francisco. Most of us also acknowledge, with some sadness, that what it costs to live here excludes 90+% of our fellow elders.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

-