The Trouble With Fort Bragg

by David Gurney, August 17, 2016

The trouble with the City of Fort Bragg, apart from its unfortunate name, can be summed up in three words: location, location, location.  From putting a mental health facility downtown at the Old Coast Hotel, to placing it's vaunted Noyo Center for Marine Science next door to a rickety sewage plant, to proposing a strip mall at the southern gates to the city, Fort Bragg's civic leaders are showing all the signs of early onset dementia, by putting things in the wrong place, like someone putting their keys in the refrigerator.

Unfortunately, Fort Bragg's problems are far more serious than that.  The most obvious problem is the western half of the city, from Main Street to the Pacific Ocean, close to 350 acres of prime but polluted oceanfront acres, is owned by the notorious Koch brothers, Charles and David.  Most people know these two plutocrats as the Koch Brothers, owners of the second largest privately held company in the United States.  The brothers are at the top thousandth of the top one percent, among the richest oligarchs on the planet, worth over 42 billion dollars apiece.  They make no secret of buying off national elections, from presidents to congress members, so directly influencing the government of a small town they own the better part of, can certainly be expected.  The old Georgia Pacific mill occupies nearly all the land west of Highway One, spanning the entire stretch of Main Street.  Once home to the biggest employer in the region, the mill site is now fenced off and abandoned, because the land was contaminated by industrial toxic waste, dumped there by the rapacious GP lumber company, also owned by the Kochs.  If our civic leaders had an impeccable record that made them immune from corruption and influence by people like the Kochs, residents of the North Coast could rest easy knowing the future of their town was in good hands.  But the town has a sordid history of mob influence, shady loans, unprosecuted arson, cronyism and back-room deals, with similar trends following to this day.

Fort Bragg's city government uses an aggressive corporate model to carry out its business.  The City Manager is Fort Bragg, Inc.'s CEO.  She pulls down the city's biggest salary at $141,000 a year, with benefits, well over $200k.  The mayor and city council,  Fort Bragg Inc's Board of Directors, make a salary of $3,600 dollars apiece. With 25k benefit packages, they each make around thirty thousand dollars yearly.  The public are the shareholders, and he who has the most shares, in the form of money and behind the scenes connections, has the most influence.  City Manager Linda Ruffing was appointed by a City Council long since gone, except for their pictures on the wall, and she has run the city for over a decade.  For six years before that she was the so-called Community Development Director, a deceptive title for someone who does not develop community, but instead greases the skids for developers.  During her decade and a half of power, she has tweaked the system to minimize public interference for plans that are frequently hatched secretly in behind-closed-door meetings.  With a lengthy track record of extremely bad judgement, compounded by an unrelenting propensity for these secret meetings, along with an unnerving smirk that resembles George W. Bush on steroids, Ruffing has made herself very unpopular among many of her Fort Bragg constituents who never elected her in the first place.  The rapid turnover of employees at City Hall, along with an underpaid and obsequious City Council that can't come up with a good idea on their own, has made Ruffing the captain of a rudderless ship.

In 2007, mayor Dave Turner and council member Doug Hammerstrom went to a conference in the Pacific Northwest, and came back with a ludicrous wave energy proposal that cost the city well over a year of exhaustive public meetings and thousands of dollars in funds.  The scheme was finally abandoned for the obvious lack of maritime infrastructure, something the public warned proponents about from the outset.  In secret meetings, the trio of Ruffing, Turner and Hammerstrom also hatched the controversial scheme to provide cush office space for privatized mental health services at the historic landmark Old Coast Hotel, in Fort Bragg's commercial district, with bed space for a mere five mental health patients.  This despite the fact that a huge Social Services building, perfect for the purposes intended, sits abandoned just across town.  They ignored massive public outcry protesting their secret policy decision, which led to recall efforts against the mayor and a ballot initiative to have the new mental health facility nixed.  Both failed.

This same trio has decided that the display of a blue whale skeleton will be the future vision for the city.  The real story of the whale, struck by a ship that was mapping for marine protected areas, ostensibly to save the type of animal that the ship in fact killed, has been neatly suppressed in the push to have the remains displayed in a glass case on the GP headlands by the so-called Noyo Center for Marine Science.  According to this vision, the display will be the centerpiece for Fort Bragg's renewal, its main tourist attraction, and with an elaborate campus, provide jobs for out-of-work Ph.D.'s.  Those who don't share this glorious vision are accused by Ruffing's clique of being "negative."

The executive director for the Noyo Center, Sheila Semans, had an interesting role in the saga of the whale skeleton, to say the least.  At the time the whale was killed, Semans was Program Manager for the California Seafloor Mapping Program (CSMP), the lead agency for an alphabet soup of state and federal agencies who, beginning in 2007, launched an extensive program to map the underwater features of the California Coast.  When the oil exploration vessel 'Pacific Star' hit the 72-foot blue whale while using side-scan mapping sonar on October 19th, 2009 just off Fort Bragg, shock waves hit the coast.  Details of the accident became a closely guarded secret, and only through persistent investigation was it found to have been operating illegally, without the required marine mammal observer that would have spotted the whale, and without proper documentation including the required offshore geophysical survey permit.  The operation was hired through Ms. Semans agency, the CSMP, for sonar surveys just before the infamous MLPA Initiative made its debut on the North Coast. The corrupt MLPA was ostensibly protecting animals such as blue whales with Marine Protected Areas, so the killing of the animal by a vessel working for that effort was a major public relations nightmare for a number of high-powered state and federal agencies.  Semans, along with her cohort Ron Levalley, came to the rescue.   LeValley acted as point man, and funds appeared out of nowhere for caterpillars, and innocent volunteers were recruited for the gargantuan task of hauling the smelly carcass up the 40-foot cliffs. The skeleton was buried for several years at a secret location, and in the time it took for microbes to eat the flesh off the bones, plans were hatched to make the whale skeleton the centerpiece for Fort Bragg's renewal, to be enshrined on the Koch brothers headlands at the old mill site, in a Snow White like glass case.  LeValley was rewarded for his efforts with the position of head of the so-called "Science Advisory Team" for the MLPA.  At the same time, in 2010, he was secretly stealing over $850,000 from the Yurok Tribe, billing them and other agencies for spotted owl surveys that he never conducted, through his "non-profit" enterprise Mad River Biologists (MRB). To add insult to injury, during the MLPA "Initiative" LeValley forbade Yurok tribal scientists from participating in the process of taking away their own ancient fishing and gathering rights.  LeValley is currently listed on the Noyo Center's web site as an "advisor." Sheila Semans, the wearer of many hats, in 2010 was "Director" at Mad River Biologists, during this same time period that the outfit was conducting its criminal embezzlement of Yurok Tribal funds.

If morphing the Program Manager of the CSMP (the agency that killed the whale) and Director of the criminal Mad River Biologists, into the Executive Director of the Noyo Center for Marine Science (the agency that will display the whale's remains) seems like an odd career trajectory, remember, this is Fort Bragg, where common sense, reality and legality are routinely turned upside down.  Last spring, our clueless House Representative Jared Huffman gave Ms. Semans an "Environmentalist of the Year Award," and Linda Ruffing has hired Sheila Semans to lead the Noyo Center - no, not in Noyo, but in Fort Bragg.  So far, the results of this tragic farce have been predictably absurd.  An A-frame visitor center that once sat high on the mill site next to Highway One, has been transported to the lowest elevation point in town, and dubbed "The Crow's Nest" by Semans, despite the fact that a crow's nest is traditionally the highest observation point on any ship.  Worse, and beyond absurd, is the fact that the marine science center, with it's whale skeleton mausoleum, has been sited by Ms. Semans on 11.5 acres directly adjacent to, and downwind of, Fort Bragg's decrepit sewer plant on property that by Fort Bragg's own documented reports, is required to have a buffer zone for olfactory and toxic chemical safety concerns.  Most municipalities require a minimum of at least 100 meters of buffer zone around such a wastewater treatment plant.

Noyo Center

Fort Bragg is not known to hide its skeletons in the closet, and instead has gone full steam ahead into the macabre business of reconstructing and displaying sea mammal skeletons in and around the city for public view.  This includes a sea lion skeleton strangely hanging in the city's Town Hall.  Another sea lion skeleton, with its human remains counterpart, adorns the "Crows Nest" visitor center next to the sewage plant.  There are plans for more whale skeletons, and sea lion skeletons, and others, as animals continue to wash ashore on the North Coast at an alarming rate, to be stripped of their flesh and displayed by these bone collectors.  Fort Bragg is on course to be known as the 'Sea World' for dead whales, and the greenwashed Noyo Center is already cashing in.

Meanwhile the Pattons, the "Group II" developers who already own two shopping centers in Fort Bragg, are plying for a third, and are railroading their project through the town's good ol' boy network with plans to develop the last bit of unspoiled open space left in the city, by installing an extremely unpopular mall at the southern gates just west of the intersection of  Highway 1 and 20.  The property is a wildlife corridor, drains into a Class 1 salmon stream, and is adjacent to the newly burgeoning Mendocino College.  Locals and visitors alike will be welcomed to Fort Bragg by a cheap "dented-can" mega-store, a 'Grocery Outlet,' along with 99 parking spaces and two other unneeded storefronts.

What can be done to prevent Fort Bragg's ship of state from going onto the rocks at Soldier's Bay, just below the mill site?   The Fort Bragg city government needs a major turnaround, starting with the firing of Linda Ruffing and Sheila Semans, and the ouster of Dave Turner as mayor.  Thankfully, the bizarrely incompetent Doug Hammerstrom is not seeking re-election and will be gone within a year.  The corporate model of a City Manager running the show needs to be abandoned, and council members need to receive a salary more in line with their actual work and responsibilities.  The Noyo Center for Marine Science needs to be relocated, from the eleven acres adjacent to the city's sewer ponds, to a more compatible place somewhere else on the mill site.  The Pattons need to abandon their plans for a strip mall at the gates to the city, in a land swap deal to a more appropriate area on the 350 acres of already developed land, nearer to the central part of town.  The last piece of unspoiled open space at the gates to the city, next to the burgeoning Mendocino College, needs to be preserved, and developed only for worthy cultural or educational purposes. Will any of this ever happen?  Time will tell whether or not the citizens of Fort Bragg will allow billion dollar players like the Kochs and their minions to secretly pull the the strings of power and completely ruin their unique coastal town, or finally take the city's destiny into their own hands.

18 Responses to The Trouble With Fort Bragg

  1. Alice Chouteau Reply

    August 17, 2016 at 1:36 pm

    Thanks for this excellent summation of the myriad troubles here, created by our mayor and cromies.
    Wasn’t the last word on the mill site, from the City, an admission that nothing will happen out there as far as development,for many decades?
    I wish you could write a whole series on these issues.
    AC

  2. joekidd Reply

    August 17, 2016 at 4:44 pm

    so as of yet; nobody has turned in papers to run for council?? so will menzies and white end up running and robovoting the ruffing way?? scary times…

    • mr. wendal Reply

      August 17, 2016 at 6:34 pm

      The deadline to file was today at 5pm. This is from an earlier AVA:

      “INCUMBENTS Hammerstrom and Deitz apparently are not running for re-election to the Fort Bragg City Council. Gressert, Johnson and Menzies are running. Heidi Kraut is expected to sign up by the Wednesday sign-up deadline. Mr. Johnson was the finance person for the City before he retired. He knows where the fiscal bodies are buried, and for that reason along will get the support of clear-thinking Fort Bragg people, as will the fiery Mr. Gressett.”

      I hope that they are all willing to take part in public debates. They should be entertaining.

  3. Jay Reply

    August 17, 2016 at 8:16 pm

    Rex did get his paperwork in on time this afternoon. And yes Mr. Wendal the debates should be great. I think there may be others who are running as well. I guess we will all find out tomorrow after the County Clerk confirms the nomination papers have 20 valid registered voters signatures. I know the City Clerk was working late today to get everything submitted to the County.

  4. BB Grace Reply

    August 18, 2016 at 6:43 am

    When I told my Mom I was relocating to Fort Bragg the first thing she said was, “Fort Bragg! I thought you hated the military.”

    Well, I hated growing up in the military. It’s one thing if you join, but it’s another to be drafted from birth. Fort Bragg was never really a Fort anyways, it was a garrison, but like much of California history, things began twisted, got more twisted and then erased with name changes because that’s how CA buries it’s shameful past, forgets it’s crimes against humanity and moves on to commit new crimes against humanity.

    The Guest House Museum stands as a witness how much those who govern the City love it. The front porch should be condemned. It is not safe. I pray everyday that no visitor gets hurt. It’s blight and a shame to see the Guest House, made from OLD GROWTH PRIME redwood rot on the spot.

    I hope Jay signed up for a council seat. If I lived within FB city limits I would vote for her, and Rex, who I’m happily suprized he’s running, as I thought he wasn’t eligable due to where he lived.

    If Rex moved to run for a Council seat I want to express how impressed and grateful I am.

  5. Debbie Reply

    August 18, 2016 at 6:52 am

    When will we allow business owners that own property and run businessis in FB but live on the outskirts of FB to run for city council ?

    • Judy Valadao Reply

      August 18, 2016 at 7:58 pm

      It probably won’t happen because it’s a State rule, but I think business owners should have some say in what happens in the downtown area.

  6. Jim Updegraff Reply

    August 18, 2016 at 2:22 pm

    ‘Early onset dementia” – wrong, The dementia has already arrived.

  7. Mature Fort Bragg Resident Reply

    August 18, 2016 at 4:23 pm

    Half Truths from a disgruntled Fort Bragg Resident who got his (Meaning that he lives out on the Pomo Bluffs). So I got mine, and scr### the rest of the town’s residents. Not sure it is jealousy or just spite that this article was conjured up. A ton of Symantec slanting does not change the facts that the Noyo Center brings in tourism that puts the food on tables of may. That an new place to shop is needed. Remember that Taco Bell and Dollar Store that no one wanted? Then why is it that there is a line at the drive thru constantly and always cars and shoppers at Dollar Tree? Always the same ten people making the same baseless claims… I for one am sick of their belly-acing.

  8. Judy Valadao Reply

    August 18, 2016 at 7:20 pm

    Mature Resident, you are right about the lines, so someone must like Taco Bell and the Dollar Store. I have always wondered: if a person owns property and does everything properly and goes by the code and pays for everything out of their own pocket how can they be told they can’t do something with that property? It is zoned for the business he wants to put in.

    As far as Georgia Pacific and toxins, let’s not forget before Georgia Pacific got here Union Lumber Company, Boise Cascade and Louisiana Pacific had already occupied and used the property. It needs to be cleaned up of course, but I don’t believe Georgia Pacific did it all on their own.

    It was Dave Turner and Scott Deitz who met with the Hospitality Center people and gave approval before the public knew what was happening with the Old Coast Hotel. Hammerstrom was not in on that but he did vote in favor of the deal.

  9. Thomas Norris Reply

    August 18, 2016 at 9:15 pm

    Fort Bragg is a-ok with me. Faced with a catastrophic economic event, the closure of the mill, the City has made great strides in developing its tourism industry. Anderson Valley should be thankful that there is such a place nearby that can put up the wine tourists that are your bread and butter at the end of the day.

    And, no, those who do not live in City should NOT have a vote. Thank goodness for sensible state law

  10. Judy Valadao Reply

    August 19, 2016 at 12:00 am

    City Council members make about a third of what is printed in this story. The insurance package at top dollar premium is about $700 per month and the salary ( without deductions) is $300-$400 per month, depending on whether or not the Municipal Improvement District meets in any given month. According to the Human Resource Dept. the salary package is worth about $12,000 per year. I can tell you that the average take home pay is about $250 per month.

    • mr. wendal Reply

      August 19, 2016 at 4:29 am

      According to Transparent California, the Mayor’s total pay and benefits for 2015 was $30,224.00, broken out as $3,600 regular pay, $1,140 other pay and $25,484 benefits (benefits are medical, dental and vision insurance for the councilmember and his or her dependents, paid 100% by the city). The other members of the council had totals as follows: Hammerstrom $25,538.00, Deitz $22,257.00, Peters $13,030.00 and Cimolino $29,984.00.

  11. Joan Hansen Reply

    August 19, 2016 at 7:54 pm

    The thing that bothers me about our town is the fact that so many shops are vacant. I can not understand why a clean industry could not be encouraged to locate here. It would hire people at good wages and offer them a benefit package of medical insurance etc. That could save the hospital which serves mostly uninsured clients. It would support families with kids benefiting the schools, it can be a town that encourages families. Tourism is not the only way and just how many trails can we develop? The mind set of the powers that be must not feel depressed as I do over the vacant stores. Rents are too high and salaries are too low here.

  12. Alice Chouteau Reply

    August 20, 2016 at 9:33 am

    The problems with chain, or formula retail and eateries, like Taco Bell and the Dollar tree are numerous. The biggest problem is that exonomically, most of the profits, sometimes 80%, leave our town and go to the corporate headquarters, so the money is not spent locally. The jobs they provide are minimum wage, usually part time, no benefits.
    I am ancient enough to remember a world before corporate fast food took over, where large cities and small towns alike had plenty of good cheap fast food options, like Jennys Burgers, that were unique and locally owned, with better food.
    Yes the City benefits from taxing chain retail, but seems to make dubious use of these funds.
    Towns and counties that have wised up and banned chain retail and formula fast food do so to protect small, locally owned busineeses, and one of the nicest amenities in Fort Bragg are the many unique food markets. Food costs are admittedly high, and maybe a locally owned, quality food co-op would help. The profits stay in the community. There are very successful co-op groceries in Eureka and Arcata, that have been popular for years, and Corners of the Mouth health food in Mendocino was started about fifty years ago and still flourishes.
    Property rights are important, but so is maintaining the character of this place.

  13. Judy Valadao Reply

    August 21, 2016 at 6:23 am

    DAVID GURNEY WRITES (on the MCN Listserve): “There are a couple of minor corrections that need to made [in Gurney’s recent AVA article “The Trouble with Fort Bragg]: One, it was Scott Deitz, not Doug Hammerstrom, who made the behind the scenes decision to use the Old Coast Hotel for Ortner office space, although Hammerstrom fully supported the move. Second, in reality, city council members make way less than the $30,000 salary mentioned in the article, since most come no where near to cashing in on the $25k benefits. Everything else stands, and then some.

  14. Alice Chouteau Reply

    August 21, 2016 at 9:53 am

    Joan
    Yes, it is too bad the City’s finanacial emphasis seems to be on getting grants and putting more money into promoting tourism, while failing to attract new businesses and families , retirees etc.
    one of the problems that discourages downtown growth and revitalization could be the fact that the City has yet to enforce fire sprinkler ordinances. Who would want to invest in a Franklin St building, knowing that most other biz have no sprinkler systems???? At tomorrow night CC meeting, the council will discuss extending the moratorium on fire sprinkler requirements for another two years!
    If the City can garner ‘tens of millions’ in grant money, why can’t they find a state or fed program to help provide loans to make the downtown fire-safe??
    The other fire threat to the core area is the number of homeless derelicts who live illegally in outbuildings, under the museum, etc. FBPD needs to enfore the laws.
    AC

  15. Jim Updegraff Reply

    August 22, 2016 at 9:25 am

    All the some towns around the country talk about bringing in a clean industry that will provide good paying jobs. It just doesn’t happen. In the case of Ft. Bragg its location is not attractive to such a business. In small towns the local young people who go to college do not return home which results in a lack of the type of workers a business would require.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *